Key West Fishing Report – Too Lethal Charters
September 22, 2025
The fishing report for Key West is that the summer pattern continues this week with forecasted winds holding steady in the 1–12 mph range. From Monday through Friday, expect primarily east winds with a touch of northeasterly influence, shifting to a more northerly direction over the weekend. Skies will be mostly sunny, with a chance of cloud cover mid-week on Wednesday and Thursday. Temperatures are forecast to remain in the mid-80s throughout the week. This all means that it’s a great week to go fish Key West!
Inshore & Flats Fishing Key West
Juvenile Tarpon have been showing up in groups, with the occasional larger fish mixed in when the conditions line up just right. Bonefish have been a welcome highlight, responding well to the warmer water temps and especially active around tide changes. Permit remain on the slow side for late September, though a few have been spotted—true to form, they’ve been as selective as ever.
On the flats in Key West, big Barracuda continue to make their presence known. They offer explosive action on fly or light spinning gear. Just remember, the faster you move the fly, the more likely you are to get their attention. Live bait is always a reliable option for these toothy predators.
Shark Fishing in Key West
Late September is a solid time for shark fishing around Key West as schools of sharks begin their seasonal migrations. Weather can play a role, with mornings generally more productive thanks to higher humidity and the chance of afternoon storms. Bull Sharks and Lemon Sharks are the primary targets this time of year, with Sharpnose Sharks also making occasional appearances.
The water remains warm, but as cooler temperatures move in, they bring more baitfish—which in turn draws more sharks into the area. Live, fresh bait is essential for success, and chumming the water increases the odds of bringing them in close. With the slower pace of tourist season, anglers have a great opportunity to get on the water and chase these powerful fish without the heavy summer crowds.
If you’re serious about fishing Key West, go with Too Lethal Charters. They’re one of the top-rated Key West offshore fishing charters. Captain Scott Gordon leads the crew. He brings energy, experience, and excitement.
Hardcore angler? You’ll love it. Family trip? It’s unforgettable. Chase sailfish offshore. Catch snapper and grouper on the reef. Fight sharks in the backcountry. Too Lethal Charters is your best choice for offshore fishing in Key West.
Offshore Fishing in Key West
Offshore anglers are enjoying a mixed bag of opportunities. Bottom fishing has produced steady catches of Snapper and Grouper. On the troll and drift, there’s been a nice variety of pelagics. You can find Wahoo, Kingfish, Barracuda, Bonita, Mahi-Mahi. I’ve also seen some Blackfin Tuna moving into the area. Sailfish have also been spotted actively hunting, adding to the excitement offshore fishing in Key West.
Meet Captain Scott Gordon – Your Expert Guide to Fishing in Key West
Captain Scott has fished Key West waters for decades. Capt. Scott knows the tides and seasons (and secret spots). Every trip is planned for success. It’s more than fishing—it’s a bucket-list experience. He tracks fish migrations and offshore conditions.
New to fishing? No problem. A seasoned pro? You’ll feel right at home. Too Lethal is one of the most trusted Key West offshore fishing charters.
Affordable Key West Offshore Fishing Without the Compromise
Fishing Key West doesn’t have to come with a high price tag. Too Lethal Charters offers affordable options, including shared charters perfect for solo anglers and small groups. You get all the action and professional service of a private trip—at a fraction of the cost.
Want to save time and money? Half-day trips (4 to 5 hours) are ideal for targeting reef species like grouper, snapper, and barracuda—perfect for maximizing value without sacrificing the thrill of the catch.
Your Ride: The 38’ “Too Lethal” Sportfishing Machine
Departing from the iconic A&B Marina in the Key West Bight, Too Lethal is a 38-foot custom Stapleton built for serious offshore fishing. With plenty of shade, comfortable seating, and top-of-the-line tackle and electronics, you’ll be ready for action in comfort and style.
Book Your Key West Fishing Charter Today!
First time in Key West? Or a returning angler? Too Lethal Charters is a top value for offshore fishing. Bring your crew. Choose your trip. Get ready for an unforgettable day on the water.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned fisherman, Too Lethal Charters offers one of the best values among all Key West fishing charters. Book today and discover why so many return year after year to fish with the best in the Florida Keys.
Grab your gear, choose your charter, and dive into an unforgettable fishing adventure! Without the high price tag. Call 305-304-1614. Mention this blog and get $150 your fishing trip! See, you’re already saving money!!!
